jay's is worthwhile visiting if only for the bar. It is a 19th bar, had carved wood and leather, about 50 feet long. The two bartenders have been there for decades and they actually know how to mix drinks. Make sure you have time for a drink at the bar before dinner.
Jay's is uneven. I ordered a combo shrimp and oysters. The shrimp were good but the coating on the oysters was soggy rather than crisp. I have had salmon, sea bass and other fish here and they were outstanding. Usually the service is good, but this time the waiter seemed overwhelmed. We had to wait 20 minutes to get our bill.