We were looking for picnic food while visiting Bayfield for the day, and happened to find this deli. My wife and daughter are vegetarians, which makes options hard to find. Fortunately, this deli had a coupe of options, while I could have something I could enjoy - especially with local flavor. They had the Hummus and Vegetable Sandwich, and I had the Smoked Whitefish Sandwich. The vegetarian sandwich was full of hummus, cucumbers, red onion, lettuce, and tomatoes, on wonderful fresh bread. They made it fresh while I was standing there, and my wife and daughter were impressed with the freshness of the ingredients, and thought the price was spot-on, especially since one could have been enough for them both. I felt the same about my sandwich: very fresh ingredients, with a nice fillet of smoked white fish. The only thing I didn’t like about my sandwich was the white ciabatta bread. I would have either preferred a wheat version, or the wheat bread offered on the other sandwich. The prices were ~$6.50 for both sandwiches. They also had fresh chocolate chip cookies just out of the oven for $0.70. My wife thought we should have bought a dozen!
I am giving the restaurant four stars versus five because my ciabatta wasn’t the best option for my sandwich, and I found out that I could have spent an extra $0.30 for chips and a pickle with a “boxed lunch”. Wish they would have let me know. Otherwise, we really enjoyed our sandwiches, and I’d highly recommend them for a great lunch on-the-go!