If you like to bite into a pizza and feel the crunch of the green peppers served on top of a perfectly done thin crust pizza...you have just found it. This is not your Chicago style loaf of mostly bread pizza served with a nondescript soggy mass of over cooked toppings. You've had the rest...now try the best.
I eat pizza for the toppings, not the thick dough Chicago bread filling carb wasteland fav of our neighbor to the south. Instead I like the thin crust, hugely dumped portions of pepperoni, Italian sausage, black olives, green and red peppers, purple onions, tomato sauce, fresh not canned mushrooms with stringy mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Every bite pops with the unique flavor of the traditional Italian pallet one would expect from a generation from the old country. I've eaten hundreds of pizzas here and have yet to be disappointed. I only Wish it had two locations.
Call in that reservation! I think the secret is out because it is getting harder and harder to get a table on Friday night and that may be their only negative. But the tables turn and they have ample parking outside so enjoy a beer at the bar while you wait. Trust me...it's worth it.
May I suggest the Papa's Deluxe which features the best of everything and pair it with a true Italian beer like a Peroni. If you like dark try a La Rosa. This combo is a keeper. Also, upgrade your garlic bread to Mama's which will be drowning in garlic butter. Top it with their marinara sauce and then cover it like a Wisconsin January snowfall with Parmesan cheese. You will wonder how you missed this delicacy. A good red wine would work too to help wash it all down.
The price is low to moderate but an excellent value. The lasagna is very good and they offer excellent fish fries and gluten free dishes. Italian oldies from Dean Martin and others serenade you in true Italian audio ambiance.
Don't miss the decor exiting the back to the parking lot. It's loaded with pictures of the rat pack, Sinatra, Martin, and movie star bombshells...and Italy's most famous export Sophia Loren.
A five star experience waiting for you in Cudahy.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.