We live about 20 minutes away from this place so we decided to give it a try. The restaurant itself looks nice from the outside but is poorly laid out on the inside. The bathroom in the dining room area was situated in a way that required you to sneak between people who were eating at their table to get into the door. One of us ordered a pasta and shrimp dish and one of us ordered almond crusted walleye. The pasta in the dish was overcooked and completely bland and unsalted. The shrimp was overcooked and chewy. The walleye dish came swimming in grease but was also completely flavorless.
The side salad and potatoes were average. When the server asked how the food was we politely stated that the pasta was mushy and flavorless. The server was not concerned in the least bit and offered no remedy.
If you pride yourself on being an Italian restaurant and you can't make noodles, something is wrong.
There are many good restaurants in the Cedarburg area,skip this one for sure.