Good pizza with a crust that is dry-crisp on the bottom, not 'greasy' crisp. Not overly smothered with cheese (unless you order a plain cheese), no skimping on the toppings.
Good brews on tap, modest salad bar, large screen TV so tends to get crowded at game time so grab your spot early. My favorites are meat-lovers and the veggie (ask for fresh tomatoes). If you are really wanting New York style, go to nearby "Italianos" or Costco (yes, Costco). None of them will have extra oregano, or know what you mean when you say "pie", but hey- it's not New York.