My husband is Italian, and we spend part of the year in Italy. We had been looking for a place by the sea. We like hiking, quiet, and great food. At Pian Delle Starze, we found all of that. The food was some of the best we have had in Italy--creative, fresh, and delicious. I loved the pre-appetizer that they brought out immediately. One evening, it was mild white fish in a parsley sauce. Another evening, it was focaccia with fabulous fresh tomatoes. Always a surprise. Gourmet quality food and wonderful wines of all kinds.
Everyone working there was extremely kind and attentive. Maria, Giuseppe, and Orlando were professional and friendly and answered all of our questions at the restaurant. Francesca, Giuseppe, and Giovanni were really helpful at the front desk. And the two housekeepers were wonderful--warm, friendly, and funny.
The location was perfect for us. We hiked to amazing beaches with perfect, clear water. If you are not a hiker, it's an easy drive down to the town to go to the beaches there.
The rooms were fine. We especially appreciated the mosquito screens. My husband is a mosquito magnet, and even if there were not very many, they would have been a torture for him. It was perfectly quiet at night, and we slept with the door to the terrace wide open.
I read a negative review that mentioned noise during the day. It's true that the quiet did not continue during the day, but it is certainly quieter than most other places. The same reviewer complained that little English was spoken. Although I speak Italian, I have always enjoyed visiting places where I have to learn a few essential phrases and then communicate with hands for the rest. Certainly Italians visiting the U.S. do not expect (and would be shocked to find) staff speaking Italian anywhere, even in a luxury hotel in a big city.
The pool and the garden were beautifully maintained and a pleasure to spend time in.