This Sheetz used to be a good stop on our trips south to Williamsburg.
The new Rt 17 bypass is one thing that screws it up. First, you still have to turn left at the light heading south to get into the store. When you leave turning right out of the light to follow Rt 17, about 1/2 mile down the road with no advance notice the road is blocked off and you have to turn back, go back to the light, turn left and the. Get in the far right lane to take the bypass to drive back by where you were just turned around. It's almost infuriating.
The store itself is not the cleanest Sheetz we've visited. The bathrooms do not smell very good and don't seem to be that well cared for. This seems to be consistent with the multiple times we've stopped here.
The food orders were slow, with what seemed like little organization behind the counter. Food was hot and good though.
I would say this Sheetz is not up to the standards that most other Sheetz or Wawa's typically seem to keep.
If you visit Sheetz often I do suggest getting a Sheetz card. It will give you discounts and freebies from time to time.