A family visit to Carlisle, PA, must always include an evening visit to Massey's Frozen Custard, which does soft-serve right. Although there is now a bit of competition in the Carlisle area for that sweet cream fix, Massey's remains highly popular with young and not-so-young alike, as it has since 1949. The order counter inside is very narrow and fills up quickly. Outdoor seating and tables is available. Sundae prices range from $3.30 (baby size) to $5.25 (3 toppings); add $.75 for hand-dipped ice cream. The Arctic Mount (thick shake, spoon only) is priced at $4.20 (small), $4.98 (medium) and $5.75 (large). I ordered a medium with Reese's and peanuts when a small would have sufficed. Novelty ice cream products are $1.50 and $2.00; cones range from $1.83 (kid) to $4.30 (4 toppings); and shakes are priced at $3.25 (small), $4.30 (medium), and $4.88 (large). A friendly warning to newcomers, warm evenings at Massey's can get a bit messy.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.