The good: Beautiful setting, great views from common room, large guest room, house has a lot of interesting detail
The OK: Proximity to road means calming river views are permeated by highway traffic noise. This bothered me more than my spouse.
The problems: Owners made us extremely uncomfortable during breakfast. Not recommended if you might ask for anything perceived to “inconvenience” them.
On arrival, we were asked when we wanted breakfast. We said 8-8:30 since we were on east coast time and wanted to get out hiking. They asked if we could do 9, and we said no. They were not pleased, especially when we asked for a vegetarian breakfast (we asked for plain scrambled eggs instead of the sausage quiche they planned; a simple request). We offered to eat breakfast elsewhere, and they said they would meet our needs “no problem” even though it was clear there was a problem. I did not sleep well because of this interaction, but the next morning everything was fine, and we even had breakfast more towards 8 am (we had already been up for over an hour, and another couple started breakfast shortly after us). The next night they saw us but did not ask if we had a different preference. Again, we were up early, but they seemed surprised and said if we had “special needs” we should have declared it on the website when we made a reservation (see note below as to why this was an impossible request). I have a visible-to-some “special need” and got so upset that I said we would just leave at eat breakfast elsewhere (I do not know if they were saying I was difficult because I had a “special need”, or my “special need” was getting up “early”). They said it would be no problem to serve us in 45 min, but we were already quite hungry and ready to go; they halfheartedly offered us toast on our way out. They said it was “no problem” that we were not having breakfast there as we left, and I said it was a problem for us, since we had paid for breakfast but were not eating it, and they had upset us a great deal. Luckily we were hiking by 9 and had a beautiful day, no thanks to our unrelaxing stay at Sandy Salmon.
Note: We booked through a third party website, and were not asked about food preferences or breakfast time. The owners said we should have booked on their website since they ask such questions. However, I called a week before to confirm my reservation and let them know what time we would arrive. No one returned my phone call and when I called back several days later I spoke with the owner. He said no problem to arrive late, and asked no other questions. I notified the third party website about their comments and they gave me a voucher because of these troubles (I am a regular customer and this is the first time I issued a complaint). Ultimately, asking for simple vegetarian items for breakfast at 8am does not seem unreasonable to me. The lodge advertises proximity to outdoor activities, and many outdoorsy people look to start before 10am! I cannot imagine how they would treat families with children who get up early.