We stayed at the Venture Resort on Kelley's Island. It was brand new August of 2008 so our room was wonderful...they were almost brand new. We were in one of the big rooms with 3 queen beds.
The price of the room included bike rental! How wonderful is that! For a family of five, 3 hours of bike rental can add up fast. When we factored that into the cost of the room that made the price very reasonable. We enjoyed the grounds and would return for a stay.
We went to Kelley's on Memorial day weekend, and did not find the island too bad. We did avoid down town and the party bars during peak hours.
I would recommend the restaurant next door for sunset dinner. We had the Filet and the Perch and both were very good.
This is a very casual, ride around the island, hike the park, hang at the beach, and look for sea glass kind of get away.More