We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

“Overpriced and average food (at best!)”
Review of Sunset Beach

Best prices for -
Check In dd/mm/yyyy Check Out dd/mm/yyyy
Prices are for 1 room, 2 adults
Show Prices
Compare best prices from top travel sites
and 2 more sites!
Sunset Beach
Ranked #5 of 5 Hotels in Shelter Island
Reviewed 4 August 2017 via mobile

$10 for a medium sized bottle of Evian. $28 for a small Niçoise salad with tinned tuna and old cherry tomatoes.
Very average service.
What a rip off!
Only plus is great view and great beach - hugely disappointing otherwise!!
Come for the beach but bring your own food and drinks!

Stayed: August 2017, travelled with family
2  Thank timetomeeow
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Write a Review
Reviews (119)
There are newer reviews for Sunset Beach
See the most recent reviews
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

6 - 10 of 119 reviews

Reviewed 24 July 2017

I am giving it two stars to highlight how dissapointed we were paying so much money for what was being managed like a beach hut. First of all, the pros:
Great vibe, some great, hard working staff, including the person killing himself to set up chairs and umbrellas in the blistering heat. The free bikes, beach chairs and umbrellas is a great plus. The vibe of the bar is great, as is the water.
Now for the cons. When we got to our room, there were many dead bugs all over the place. Perhaps the room had been empty, but c'mon - get a mop and clean it. For over $500 a night it should be crisp and clean. The glasses for morning orange juice were visibly disgusting, and the silverware with our crossaints were also dirty.
If the hotel wants to rest on its laurels, it will have customers and continue to be booked on weekends by the rich and famous, but will lose the benefit of returning weekday customers when it would have been so easy to keep us. Hope they take my advice.
At the end of the day, we did have a good time, but not without feeling like we did not get what we paid for.

  • Stayed: July 2017, travelled as a couple
    • Sleep Quality
    • Cleanliness
    • Service
2  Thank nicoli
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Reviewed 18 July 2017

The setting is stunning, the restaurants and bar buzzing and the food great.............but the rooms are a disgrace. We travelled from London for a birthday. Arrived late at night, no toilet paper in the room, a broken toilet seat, a sink that didn't drain, a hairdryer that didn't work, a curtain hanging off its hooks, a dirty terrace......how can they charge $500 a night for rooms no better than a motel.

  • Stayed: July 2017, travelled with friends
    • Sleep Quality
    • Cleanliness
    • Service
4  Thank Gareth L
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Reviewed 20 May 2017 via mobile

I planned a romantic 2nd anniversary weekend here with my husband. My uncle died suddenly after discovering he had stage 4 cancer. He didn't want a funeral but instead requested a memorial service with the entire family participating. I called the hotel to explain this and she was extremely cold and said I would lose $240 and that they were a small hotel and there was nothing she could do(with absolutely no remorse). I asked to speak to the manager and she said she was the manager. So I said I guess I would just have to keep it because I can't afford to spend that much on another 2nd anniversary weekend. After we hung up she had the gall to chase me for a cancellation! They must be desperate for cash to be so rude to someone who is in a period of grieving. Be ware they are greedy and do not put customers first.

Stayed: May 2017, travelled as a couple
5  Thank elizabethbaisley
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Reviewed 7 November 2016

I wanted to like Sunset Beach, but their propensity for astronomical charges with average delivery wore thin. The staff are mainly kids on a summer vacation. So, they're hung over while serving over-priced breakfast. The reception invite you to go to the bar yourself when you ask for ice. They, comically, close reception at 10pm. The bar / restaurant booms music way past midnight and every room feels it. Wine is marked up by a factor of 3. Whispering Angel rose is $20 at the local store and $60 in the minibar. A crudite board of chopped radishes and tomatoes was $23 (I think). The ingredients cost $2 max. Nor is Shelter Island miles from civilisation or accessible by boat only one day a week. The hostesses in the restaurant are tediously glum in that way that hot girls sometimes think appropriate. All very dull.
It's a funny thing this over-charging game... I don't think anyone's really having fun. The customers are irritable, and rightly so. They staff are on the receiving end. And the owner is presumably miles away in a big house. The most glaring omission was a manager overseeing it all, managing the detail, making it hard to complain because everything is so great. It wasn't, so it was very annoying.

  • Stayed: August 2016, travelled with friends
    • Location
    • Sleep Quality
    • Service
6  Thank deepoceansw1
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Hotels you might also like...
Also consider these accommodations in or near Shelter Island
3.6 km away
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin Hotel
#3 of 5 in Shelter Island
240 reviews
2.6 km away
Shelter Island House
Shelter Island House
#1 of 5 in Shelter Island
72 reviews
4.2 km away
Sound View Greenport
Sound View Greenport
#1 of 7 in Greenport
594 reviews
Show Prices
Show Prices
Show Prices
1.5 km away
Harborfront Inn at Greenport
11.1 km away
Baron's Cove
Baron's Cove
#1 of 5 in Sag Harbor
245 reviews
3.7 km away
Cliffside Resort Condominiums
Show Prices
Show Prices
Show Prices

Been to Sunset Beach? Share your experiences!

Write a Review Add Photos & Videos

Additional Information about Sunset Beach

Address: 35 Shore Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11965-2002
Region: United States > New York > Long Island > Hamptons > Shelter Island
Bar / Lounge Beach Children Activities (Kid / Family Friendly) Restaurant Room Service Wheelchair access
Hotel Style:
Ranked #5 of 5 Hotels in Shelter Island
Price Range: €163 - €188 (Based on Average Rates for a Standard Room)
Hotel Class:3 star — Sunset Beach 3*
Number of rooms: 20
Reservation Options:
TripAdvisor is proud to partner with Booking.com and Agoda so you can book your Sunset Beach reservations with confidence. We help millions of travellers each month to find the perfect hotel for both holiday and business trips, always with the best discounts and special offers.
Also Known As:
Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island
Sunset Beach Shelter Island

Is This Your TripAdvisor Listing?

Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.

Claim Your Listing