We stayed 2 nights at Sunset Beach to celebrate our anniversary. We emailed ahead to make sure we got a room farthest from the restaurant which I was happy with and we thought we had better views. I thought everything was absolutely charming in a chic laid back European coastal way. We noticed some reviews mentioned there were no water views- there were definitely water views. The deck we had was large with great sun loungers and a matching table and chair that we used to watch the sunset. The room was just as described and we liked the simplistic beach elegance of it with yellow and white stripe accents and bright white. The bed was definitely comfortable and the shower head powerful. Beach service was great, the attendant was always available quickly for any needs. When we would call down to ask for something it would be brought moments later. Our 2 points of feedback though, that inhibited us from giving this another star though was the fact the housecleaning team forgot to replace towels and the bathmat so we had to call down. The 2nd point was there was an odd rusty stain under the glass table in the living area that should have been cleaned but clearly hasn't been. Other than that, we loved it and would definitely return! We loved the restaurant as well! Cocktails were great, and we thought the service thorough. Get a table for sunset on the top deck and ENJOY!
- Reservation Options:
- TripAdvisor is proud to partner with Booking.com and Agoda so you can book your Sunset Beach reservations with confidence. We help millions of travellers each month to find the perfect hotel for both holiday and business trips, always with the best discounts and special offers.
- Also Known As:
- Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island
- Sunset Beach Shelter Island