We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Nearby Hotels
West Neck Guesthouse(Shelter Island Heights)(Great Value!)
Booking.com
View Deal
  • Free Wifi
  • Free Parking
Shelter Island House(Shelter Island)(Great Value!)
US$664
Official Site
View Deal
  • Free Wifi
  • Free Parking
Seven on Shelter - a boutique b&b hotel(Shelter Island Heights)
TripAdvisor
View Deal
Certificate of Excellence
  • Free Wifi
  • Free Parking
The Chequit(Shelter Island Heights)
TripAdvisor
View Deal
Certificate of Excellence
  • Free Wifi
  • Free Parking
House on Chase Creek(Shelter Island Heights)
TripAdvisor
View Deal
  • Free Wifi
  • Free Parking
The Pridwin Hotel(Shelter Island)
TripAdvisor
View Deal
  • Free Wifi
  • Free Parking
Reviews (123)
Filter reviews
123 results
Traveller rating
30
26
21
18
28
Traveller type
Time of year
LanguageAll languages
30
26
21
18
28
Show reviews that mention
All reviewssummer weekendferry ridevibedjluxe
Filter
Updating list...
17 - 22 of 123 reviews
Reviewed 24 August 2016

Too cool for school. That's what the staff are like at this trendy beach front place. Great bar. Good food. Shabby decor. Dead insects in the drinks. Very buzzy. Tables too crammed in for me. Constantly being knocked by waiting staff and other customers. It's a pretty cool place but don't put money on any of the staff cracking a smile or making you feel valued. They don't care about the customer. The sort of staff to whom I really object to having to pay the 20%.

  • Stayed: August 2016, travelled with family
    • Location
    • Service
Thank jae39
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Reviewed 22 August 2016

I like going early to avoid the crowds - breakfast is very limited - a few choices of crepes, quiche,pasteries, smoked salmon & bagel and great coffee - all excellent - friendly staff ...you order at the counter and take food to your table - informal style with some great music and a view across the street of beach & boats and the occasional sea plane landing & taking off - it is different, international, very fun for breakfast. In past years I have had dinner & lunch - always a little different each time and sometimes a very crazy scene.

Room Tip: ate here only
  • Stayed: August 2016, travelled with friends
    • Location
    • Service
Thank SagHarborAlice
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Reviewed 19 August 2016 via mobile

We spent 4 nights at the Sunset Beach.
The spot is really nice and the sunset amazing but unfortunately the place is very overpriced considering the lack of service: hard to find someone to help you with the luggage which were heavy considering we are traveling from Europe, no service at night in the room, self service for breakfast at the price of a 5 star hotel.
The room are nice but once again not well maintained: don't look below the stained carpet you might get frightened, damaged wooden floor, dust in the closet.
Regarding the restaurant, the food and the setting are really nice, but once again really overpriced and the white seat cushion would need a cleaning from time to time...
Overall we liked it there, not sure though we will recommend it.

Stayed: August 2016, travelled with family
Thank Valérie j
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Reviewed 24 May 2016

My sister and I stopped at Sunset Beach last summer (August of 2015) for a very late lunch (or very early dinner). We also wanted to see how the hotel has changed since we vacationed on Shelter Island when we were kids. Our grandfather owned a home on the island from 1930 until 1985 so my mother and her siblings and then my sister and I (and our cousins) spent every summer on the Island during our childhoods. Of course it has changed but not as dramatically as one would think-we go back every couple of years for long weekends. I would not normally review a hotel/restaurant based on how it was decades ago and this is the only review of any hotel or restaurant on the island that I have written (altho' I do plan on writing about the Ram's Head after we visit in June of 2016). ANYWAY, it is pricey. We had one drink each (each drink cost $18) and some light food and while the food was tasty, the service was lacking. After our food and drinks were delivered after an excessive wait, that was the last we saw of our waiter. The deck bar/restaurant was SO packed and with so many small children running around, it was far from relaxing or even enjoyable. But it is more that the hotel advertises itself as being a "seaside hideaway" with "breathtaking views" (these are all words from their website) that struck us as being a bit disingenuous. It's far from a "hideaway" since the beach is the town beach and there is a steady flow of cars passing by. The bars and restaurant (and hotel itself) is right on the road-look at the website photos to understand that you are not staying (or eating) in some quiet location on any particularly exceptional beach. The beach is long but narrow-the photos on the website must have been taken at low tide since it was and always has been a....narrow beach on the Long Island Sound with views of the north fork of Long Island. Just be aware of this before you book a stay or even eat here because you are paying a LOT for not much (except the name associated with the group of hotels owned by a man with a fancy French name).

  • Stayed: August 2015, travelled with family
    • Value
    • Sleep Quality
    • Service
1  Thank LWD01915
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
Reviewed 13 October 2015

Nice hotel, nice restaurant. The rooms are a tiny bit dated compared to the "trendiness" of the place but the location and the vibe is still great.
It's a bit of a scene, no random dressers there.
Very French, every time we go there for lunch or dinner, the waiters and at least half of the customers speak French.
The location (right on the beach) is ideal for families with little kids (like us), and staying at the hotel also solves the parking issue - although we've discovered a few breath taking public beaches with barely anyone...
For us, the contrast complete-nature/hyper-civilized-hotel is kind of fun.

  • Stayed: July 2015, travelled with family
    • Rooms
    • Cleanliness
    • Service
Thank Juliette M
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC
View more reviews