We've been going to Cape for 4 years now and we make reservations at Pisces 2x each 7 day trip. Its that good. Everyone in family agrees - its that good. Its not cheap - but no seafood restaurant is cheap. You need to reserve at least a week in advance and even then you get 6pm or 9pm. So plan ahead.
The Risotto of the day is best deal - full bowl of Risotto covered with some type of large piece of fish. Always amazing flavors. Fish is the best - just cannot say enough about how fresh and well prepared.
Dont miss the Tres Leches dessert. We were next to a table of 10 - all 10 ordered Tres Leches - its that good. Other desserts are good too - but make sure at least one person in your party gets Tres Leches.
Appetizers are great - the kids make us bring them home the Margarita Pizza.