My husband and I tried this restaurant about week after they home back a couple of years or so but the pizza crust was very soggy and the service was not very good that particular night. They just didn't seem ready for "prime time." Friends and I went back last week and order a Margherita Pizza to share. It was delicious but unfortunately only slightly warm. When our waitress came back to ask how things were I told her and she immediately said "well it just came out of the oven." No, not unless there was something wrong with the oven. She did ask if we wanted another pizza but we were going to a play and didn't have the time to wait for another pizza and we were sure reheating would spoil the one we had. All that said, the taste of the pizza and the crust was excellent. We hail from Boston where there is no shortage of authentic pizza and we've been searching for the real thing since we moved to the Cape 10 years ago. We found it right in our own town of Brewster. We'll definitely come back and next time we'll ask that it be served as soon as it comes from the oven. I am also interested to try their calzones and pasta dishes.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.