We did make a reservation, we did wait 30 mins for the table. Food good, period. Not great but good. I had the steak and it was maybe B to B+ quality. Nothing to write home about. But something is wrong with all these fabulous ratings, It is not a fabulous place by any means. I think most are bogus. Its a average place, overpriced but the food is good. For the Keys I would say it's above average as most places are truly dumps. I will return but I cant say it one of my top 100 places to eat but for the Keys is good. Average at best.
If your looking for a heavy poor this is not the place.