We booked Waterfront Brewery for a large group of guests for our wedding party and had an awesome time. They reserved us all tables in the game room area (it's almost impossible to make large reservations at Key West restaurants we have found out), kept in touch with us regularly, and accommodated our very large party (40+ guests) quite comfortably. The food was amazing as usual (we have been to Waterfront a few times now); we started out with appetizers and many of our guests re-ordered appetizers for their meals because of how good they were. Waterfront also has a great fresh seafood selection which is a personal must for me, and the beer is top quality. They had a peanut butter beer on tap that was a favorite for the group. Our guests said of all the nights they spent in Key Wests this dinner was the one the enjoyed the most.