We like to try different pizza/italian places when traveling. Rotolo's was both good and disappointing:
Kudos: Not bad pizza and we left full and satisfied.
Disappointing: Nothing really stands out about this place. Service was of course pitiful. We won't be back.
If you want a place you can take a bunch of people and get a pizza, some drinks and hang out this is a good option. But it's not the "hidden gem" you may be looking for in my opinion.