I am sorry to hear that Pumpkin Hill is now only open for catered events. I would have loved to return for another meal. We attended a lovely wedding reception at Pumpkin Hill over the weekend. Pumpkin Hill is a beautiful venue overlooking Cayuga Lake. The sunset was perfect the night of the reception! The food was a pleasant surprise, not your typical wedding menu. We were treated to a delicious buffet of BBQ spareribs, BBQ chicken, pulled pork, pasta salad with roasted vegetables, tossed salad and corn bread. Staff was friendly and attentive. Appetizers consisted of cheese, crackers, fruit and a unique pretzel bar with three different toppings. A wonderful evening and memorable wedding!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.