First off, wife and I were here in off-season, so the operational days were limited and the restaurant wasn't fully operational, so I can't speak to that. They did have a pop-up burger option on Saturday that was absolutely delicious. (Lamb, Beef).
We stayed in the village for 3+ weeks. I believe that contributed to our experience. The best part of this pub is the people, and a close 2nd is the atmosphere. Alan and Katryn were very welcoming. Several other local patrons were also very welcoming. We made several friends, had some great discussions, and some great Guinness. When St Patrick's Day rolled around, a surprise was that some of our new friends were musically inclined and the whole late afternoon/night was filled with music. For our longer stay, I specifically selected a small village for the possibility of small pub environment, and getting to know the locals. My wife and I are thoroughly overjoyed with the random luck of picking a town that had The Otter in it, and it will forever hold a special place in our hearts for everyone we met, the atmosphere, and the conversations had. Alan, thank you SO much for making our stay so memorable! S'lainte and Good luck! ~Marty & Jen (the Americans)

This place is an absolute joke. The staff were rude and we definitely did not feel welcome here. We left our drinks and went to a much better bar. I later found out none of the locals drink here which does not surprise me.

What an extraordinary place to spend a couple hours on our last day in Ireland. Alan and Catrin exude all the friendliness of Ireland in one lovely pub. Bartenders, friends, tour guides, and the best Guinness we’ve had in Ireland. We’re just sorry we missed the music they have on offer during the weekend.

Fantastic service and lovely friendly people. This was a lovely friendly welcome. Thank you and we will be back. GERRY AND AGNES

Recently visited the beautiful village of Inistioge and went into the Otter bar for food and drinks. The staff are so welcoming and the owners are so kind and helpful. Drink is amazing and food is outstanding. I would highly recommend this bar to anyone looking for a happy fun night in the village of Inistioge!!!! Will definitely return
Alan and Catherine are the best publicans I have ever met ! Fabulous people