We eat here whenever we are in St Thomas -- 3 or 4 times a year for several years -- and we've never been disappointed. The dishes on the standard menu are good, but we've found their specials to be even better. Especially the pasta of the day. It has never been anything less than excellent and many times it has been superb. The servers are experienced, the owner is friendly, and the atmosphere is charming.
We also like "Room with a View", which does have a great view and really good food, but it is never quite as good as the pasta special at Amalia Cafe. We also like "Wicked" at Yacht Haven Grande, whose menu has both a cheap side and an expensive side; the food is very good, but can't quite beat the pasta special at Amalia Cafe; Wicked does have a somewhat more lively atmosphere, so for a party feel this is where we go, as Amalia Cafe is usually pretty quiet.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.