my friend & i, both 56, go away every xmas (hubbies have to fend for themselves @ home!) & are debating among the 3 islands listed above. we love to hike, do a little shopping, sight-see, visit historic sites, hang out at the beach, & read. we're pescatarians (fish only - no meat) & rarely "imbibe in tasty adult beverages."
as far as accommodations, cleanliness (or lack thereof) is really the only deal-breaker, &, of course, being close to, or on, the beach would be a big plus. we have no preference as to if we stay at an inn, hotel, or b&b.
are any of these islands easier to get to than another?
suggestions and advice are needed!
would it be helpful to post this on all three forums, or will this 1 suffice?