There are not any cideries close to Buffalo, unfortunately. There is Blackbird Cider Works in Barker, which is about an hour away. Unfortunately, I don't find any of their ciders to be good. Cider Creek in Canisteo is very good, but is about two hours away.
Leonard Oakes winery in Medina (also about an hour away) makes "Steampunk Cider" which is great. It's also available at many liquor stores in the area.
McKenzie's used to be produced by Mayer Brothers, but as of last year it no longer is.
There's a handful of good cideries in the Finger Lakes.
Premier has a pretty good selection. If you go to the one on Maple, they carry cider in both the liquor section and the "gourmet" section.
Thanks! Premier Wine & Spirits was amazing!