We are spending one night in the general area. We do plan to visit Mackinac Island, but a day trip should satisfy us. Which is the best to spend the night Mackinaw City, Mackinac Island or St. Ignace? We don't want a cheapo place, nor are we seeking luxury. Just looking for a nice overnight spot. It's difficult to differentiate the hype of touristy spots from the possibility of nothing there in the non-tourist places.
I appreciate your input!