We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Virginia
Level Contributor
266 posts
27 reviews
Save Topic
Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Traveling from the east coast. We only have two nights in Healdsburg for dinner. What are the positives and negatives of Guiso vs Mateo restaurants?

Mentioned in this post
Healdsburg
Healdsburg
Sonoma County, CA
8 replies to this topic
California
Level Contributor
103 posts
6 reviews
Save Reply
1. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Hmm those are two that I'd probably be least likely to choose out of all the restaurants in Healdsburg. If you've got two nights, where are you going the other night?

Mentioned in this post
Healdsburg
Healdsburg
Sonoma County, CA
Virginia
Level Contributor
266 posts
27 reviews
Save Reply
2. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Thank you for your reply. We have a Thursday and Friday for dinner somewhere with a vineyard event on Saturday. I have a reservation at SHED on Friday but I have also considered Chalkboard. In the past we have been to Baci and Barndiva.

Mentioned in this post
Chalkboard
Chalkboard
542 Reviews
Healdsburg, CA
Barndiva
Barndiva
638 Reviews
Healdsburg, CA
California
Level Contributor
103 posts
6 reviews
Save Reply
3. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Chalkboard is fantastic as is Campo Fina, Willi's and Brass Rabbit. Diavola in Geyserville is amazing. I always think of the SHED more as a breakfast/lunch place but they do that well so I'm sure their dinner is great too, the dining area is more cafe like than cozy restaurant.

Now as for your original question, I've never been to Guiso but it gets great reviews on yelp and I always look at the menu when I walk by. Cozy restaurant with a small number of tables.

Mateo isn't my favorite though I couldn't pin point why.

Mentioned in this post
Chalkboard
Chalkboard
542 Reviews
Healdsburg, CA
Campo Fina
Campo Fina
361 Reviews
Healdsburg, CA
Diavola
Diavola
550 Reviews
Geyserville, CA
Virginia
Level Contributor
266 posts
27 reviews
Save Reply
4. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Thank you for your help! I wouldn't have guessed that about SHED based upon the reviews. I have also had a eye on Brass Rabbit. We stopped at Willi's Wine bar in Santa Rosa on a previous trip. Hmm...decisions, decisions.

Mentioned in this post
Santa Rosa
Santa Rosa
Sonoma County, CA
California
Level Contributor
103 posts
6 reviews
Save Reply
5. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

The Willi's in Healdsburg vs SR is more seafood and cocktails. You might also want to check out Bravas which has the same owners as Willi's. Their back patio is beautiful and they have the best happy hour prices around (only mon-thurs though so that might not work with the times you'll be visiting).

I'd do SHED for a breakfast or lunch (they make the best cappuccino in town imo) and go to Willi's for a cocktail and appetizer then Brass Rabbit for dinner and finish up the night on the patio at Bravas for a g&t and their soft serve with olive oil and salt! That's an outline of my perfect evening! :)

Mentioned in this post
Healdsburg
Healdsburg
Sonoma County, CA
Bravas
Bravas
622 Reviews
Healdsburg, CA
Desert Southwest US
Level Contributor
1,084 posts
2 reviews
Save Reply
6. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Mateo...ugh....yikes.

I'd opt for Campo Fina or Diavola. The latter is definitely worth the short drive to Gville.

In town, El Farolito is one of my favorites, make sure to sit at the bar and see Chuy. He will make you something very pleasing.

Mentioned in this post
Campo Fina
Campo Fina
361 Reviews
Healdsburg, CA
Diavola
Diavola
550 Reviews
Geyserville, CA
Desert Southwest US
Level Contributor
1,084 posts
2 reviews
Save Reply
7. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

I'd add that I have been a cheerleader for Guiso...my experiences in there have been hit and miss though. Wonderful people.

Virginia
Level Contributor
266 posts
27 reviews
Save Reply
8. Re: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please

Thanks for your info. This is very helpful. On our last trip we stayed in Guernville. While it was absolutely lovely we missed the convenience of being able to walk to so many excellent dining options.

Reply to: Guiso or Mateo for dinner please
Get notified by e-mail when a reply is posted
Get answers to your questions about Healdsburg
More Healdsburg Topics