We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Want the lowest hotel prices? You're in the right place. We check 200+ sites for you.

Italian Restaurants in Setauket

Sort by:
Relevance
Ranking
Name
We found great results, but some are outside Setauket. Showing results within 40 km of Setauket.
Limit search to Setauket.

Mario's Italian Restaurant (East Setauket 0.7 km away)

#1 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (2)
Matched on: Italian

Via Pizza (East Setauket 0.7 km away)

#2 of 91 Results
Map
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Mario's Italian Kitchen Incorporated (East Setauket 0.7 km away)

#3 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Matched on: Italian

Setauket Village Diner (East Setauket 0.0 km away)

#4 of 91 Results
Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu
Matched on: American Diner Italian Greek

Bliss (East Setauket 1.4 km away)

#5 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (11)
Menu
Matched on: American Italian French

Ruvo Restaurant East (Port Jefferson 3.5 km away)

#6 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (13)
Menu
Matched on: Italian American Gluten Free Options
Reserve

Pasta Pasta (Port Jefferson 3.6 km away)

#7 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (14)
Menu
Matched on: Italian International Gluten Free Options
Reserve

Pentimento Restaurant (Stony Brook 3.9 km away)

#8 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (10)
Menu
Matched on: Italian
Reserve

Pie (Port Jefferson 3.6 km away)

#9 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Luigi's Pizzeria & Restaurant (East Setauket 0.2 km away)

#10 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu
Matched on: Pizza Italian

Station Pizza & Brew (Stony Brook 2.6 km away)

#11 of 91 Results
Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Pizza Carnival (Port Jefferson Station 5.0 km away)

#12 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (2)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza Seafood
Reserve

Ralphs famous Italian ice (Port Jefferson 3.5 km away)

#13 of 91 Results
Map Menu
Matched on: Italian

Fratellis Market Place (Stony Brook 3.9 km away)

#14 of 91 Results
Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza Delicatessen

Colosseo (Port Jefferson Station 5.6 km away)

#15 of 91 Results
Map
Visitor photos (6)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Vincenzo's Pizza (Port Jefferson 3.5 km away)

#16 of 91 Results
Map Menu
Matched on: Italian

The Trattoria (Saint James 7.0 km away)

#17 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (18)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Setauket Pastaria (East Setauket 4.6 km away)

#18 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (15)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza
Reserve

Renzo's Pizza & Restaurant (Mount Sinai 6.3 km away)

#19 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map Menu
Matched on: Pizza Italian

O Sole Mio (Stony Brook 7.2 km away)

#20 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (7)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza
Reserve

Vito's of Port Jefferson (Port Jefferson Station 5.2 km away)

#21 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (2)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Lombardi's On The Sound (Port Jefferson 5.6 km away)

#22 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (17)
Menu
Matched on: Italian American

Orto (Miller Place 9.1 km away)

#23 of 91 Results
€€€€ Map
Visitor photos (7)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Amici (Mount Sinai 7.0 km away)

#24 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (6)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Manhattan Pizza (Stony Brook 6.7 km away)

#25 of 91 Results
Map
Visitor photos (1)
Menu
Matched on: Pizza Italian

Savino's Hideaway (Mount Sinai 8.1 km away)

#26 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (5)
Menu
Matched on: Italian

Cafe Spiga Pizzeria & Ristorante (Mount Sinai 7.5 km away)

#27 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Rocco's Pizzeria and Ristorante (Mount Sinai 6.5 km away)

#28 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Old Town Pizzeria (Port Jefferson Station 6.8 km away)

#29 of 91 Results
Map Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza

Caligiuri's Patio Pizza (Saint James 7.9 km away)

#30 of 91 Results
€€ - €€€ Map
Visitor photos (4)
Menu
Matched on: Italian Pizza