We were touring through Custer state park and decided it was lunch time and we would stop in Custer. This time of year not much is open and seeing that Pizza Mill was busy we decided to stop. What a wonderful little pizza shop and...More
1 - 10 of 158 reviews
This tiny place which is spotless and old time decor offers great pizza with a bit of a different flavoring. Family owned place. Love the dough.
Great find this trip - good pizza that the locals recommend. One type of crust but lots of topping variety.
Our family went to Custer on vacation and after asking some locals for a good pizza place in town, we were referred to the Pizza Mill. After a long day of being on our feet, we were looking forward to some good pizza and an...More
We went in this past Tues eve (8/15/17) and spent a few min just standing around before the young lady came out of the back and told us it was counter service. We ordered three pizzas, two plain cheese and one with mushrooms and olives....More
We had 2 pizzas plus a Calzone. Pizzas were really good - the crust is thick but chewy and tasty. We ate in the restaurant; it was clean - a bit small but they had tables outside too. A decent place to get pizza in...More
Reminded me of a Seinfeild episode. Food was good but sat there quit a while before they mentioned to order at counter, a sign would be nice. The 4 slices of cheese bread came with one additional topping besides the cheese. Asked if we could...More