The Old Fashioned has a great atmosphere and it's namesake is make the old fashioned supper club way of tester year. If you aren't a cocktail fan they also have lots of local brews to try.
1 - 10 of 1,754 reviews
Went with a group of people from a training class I am on town for. Everything was great. We had cheese curds, beer cheese soup, summer sausage sandwich on rye, the old fashion burger, the fried perch special. Between all of us, we tried many...More
Great place to drink and grab an good dinner. More of a loud party atmosphere. Be prepared to wait for a table if you try to go on Friday or Saturday. Not high end, but not your average restaurant either. Cheese curds are some of...More
Arrive early as there will likely be a line! Cheese curds are a must. Dishes are nicely prepared and reasonably priced. Don't forget an Old Fashioned to start the meal off right (Wisconsin tradition). I had #35, portobello/egg plant sandwich which was very flavorful. Mac...More
Great location on capital square and an easy walk from several downtown hotels. The restaurant offers a good selection of food and the kitchen accommodated my dietary needs. Down side was the noise. We were there on a Friday night and although we waited an...More
Easily the best cheese curds in Madison! The ranch is on point as well. Every entree I've tried has been fantastic. Service is good but not spectacular - which has as much to do with how consistently crowded this place gets. Bartenders are consistently good...More
The Old Fashion is right across the street from the Wisconsin State Capital. I had the No. 36, the Walleye Sandwich, very tasty. The place is very popular and was packed during our meal. The service was outstanding with just enough touch points.