The pizza was really good. We ordered the 3 Burroughs pizza with 5 meats and enjoyed the meal immensely. My daughter ordered the ziti and it was good but lots and lots of cheese.
1 - 10 of 39 reviews
OMgosh-this place has the most delicious pizza around. Thin crust and just like NY pizza. The single slices are like 2 slices in one. The subs are OK so I just stick with the pizza. They do offer other Italian dishes but again--I go for...More
The chicken wings were dry and had no flavor. The pizza was undercooked. I've never had undercooked pizza at any other pizza place. Mario's use to be good but not anymore. I would not go back. Not to mention it's more expensive than other pizza...More
At Mario's you always get fast and friendly service. When you buy a slice...that slice is HUGE but you don't loose any taste or flavor. It is so yummy. Don't be fooled if you go in around lunch time and look around and don't see...More
I go here and get a slice or two or if I'm getting for multiple people, I purchase a couple large pizzas. Large quantities with the usual toppings available everywhere else. Moderately priced and the slices are big.
My big, extended family (and lots of our friends) really like Mario's NY-style pizza, subs and calzones, and they eat there a lot! And now that Mario's has gluten-free pizza, I can at Mario's, too. :) Their gluten-free crust is really delicious. As for toppings,...More
Visited early in the week at supper. Had never been there before, but was highly recommended to me. I was not disappointed at all. That one piece of pizza was a meal, and the garlic knots were delicious. The only negative was that the garlic...More
Was hoping ut was just the Wendover location that had gone down hill, so we tried New Garden. They have same issue, seems lije it must be a teaching issue. Mario's used to be our go-to place, but over the last couple years crust has...More
I've stopped in here a few times at the suggestion of a friend. It's a good slice, but not cheap. The last time I was in, the crust could have been crisper, but that's really my only complaint