Pie is pretty good. Shabby-chic location, near a small pier.No coffee/tea, only water or lime juice.
1 - 10 of 60 reviews
My wife and I had greatly enjoyed Steve's key lime pies in the past and decided it would be fun to cap our driving lesson this past Sunday with a trip to his store for pies and a walk in the nearby park. As soon...More
Key lime pies here are absolutely delicious. The one with Belgian chocolate is only available from the shop - so be sure to try it. Assuming you don't have a car, you can take the B61 bus and get off at the corner of Van...More
Yes, this is a very true statement! I've tried "other" key lime pies, but I have to say that Steve's pies always rise to the top of the list! Even though I live on the other side of the country, I won't go anywhere else...More
First, it a very tiny place that has stuff lying all over. Made me feel like it was unclean. I didn't expect that considering they are selling you something your going to eat. I guess it was the feel of the waterfront brought indoors. Anyway,...More
We are first and foremost a commercial bakery, with our wholesale outlet for take-out only, so no plates. The "stuff laying all around" is what we call "decoration," and most people seem to enjoy the variety of items we have on display. You can rest...More
Steve's pies are amazing. The key lime favor really stands out. And the texture perfectly matches with the crust to make for a very pleasant experience in your mouth. When out of town friends visit we love to bring them here for both the pies...More
I love key lime pie, and Steve's is great. But, it is incredibly expensive. Marie Calendars is almost as good and it's 1/4 the price. Check it out once.More
Thanks for your review, but as a business owner in NYC, I rarely complain about prices in NYC. Unless you've dealt with rent, insurance, regulatory strangling (it's a long list,) I don't think people have a clear idea of the cost of doing business in...More
By far the best Key Lime Pie in NYC! Also has the best view of the Statue of Liberty. Get a small one to eat immediately and frozen one for later!