This is the location where you go up to the counter order your food and then go back up when they call your number that it's ready. The pizza is closer to New England Style if that's what you like.
11 - 20 of 1,109 reviews
After reading so many reviews about how this would be the best pizza I ever had, how delicious it was, etc., my husband and I decided to try this place for ourselves. We've had some of the best pizza in place like NYC, Hartford, and...More
Pizza was oversold by my hotel. The pizza was fair at best, nothing special. Very bland in flavor. Pizza was worth half of what I paid for. The guy answering the phone was rude and inhospitable. He answered the phone on Sunday night at 9...More
Not a great place to go if you are looking for atmosphere, but if you are looking for great pizza with fantastic crust then this is the place to go
The Town was busy - long waits for food.... so we went to Tommy's for dinner. We found a 1/2 hour wait just for pizza...... but clearly everyone loves their pizza. We had 20+ orders ahead of us with standing room only. The pizza was...More
Pepperoni and mushroom pizza was very good, especially the sauce on the pizza. Greek salad and dressing were fresh and a good size. Service was prompt, friendly and helpful. All around it was a very good lunch.
We stop at Tommy's every time we visit Gettysburg. Yes the place is old but the pizza is delicious! We never had any issues with service or the food.
We had planned to go to Dobbin House Tavern, but there was an hour wait plus it is NOT handicapped accessible. So, we found Tommy's. It is a typical quick place for pizza. What is not typical is the great quality of their pizza. You...More
We ordered pizza on a Sunday evening for carryout. I went inside to get it. The place was pure chaos. Unfriendly staff. Pizza was fine, would never need to try again.