The last time I was there was a couple of years ago. Went back today and saw they're even better. The sandwiches are as delicious as always, but innovations like the powdered peanut butter have made the place even more of a must-visit than before.

This place is amazing if you love peanut butter! They have the best menu ever!! When I am back in the city I will be going back.

I think this place would be perfect for late breakfast since their sandwiches were so yummy! I was here with two friends and we enjoyed everything we orderes. Very cute design too!

Sometimes one goes to a spot they see on TV and it disappoints no end. Not Peanut Butter &Co. I hadn't had fresh made peanut butter this good since I was a kid and would go on family trips to PA Dutch country. We split...More

If you have ever had their peanut butter you will be in for a surprise when you see the menu options of choices. It takes awhile to get your food for it being a peanut butter sandwich but it's worth the wait!!

So I love that this exists in the West Village. There is a small menu of different peanut butter sandwich creations; both sweet and savory. I've tried a few and they have all been delicious. Peanut Butter Co peanut butters are amazing. They are really...More

Ii recently visited the peanut butter co. shop and ended up buying 4 jars of their peanut butter. Im from india , and had to carry them back, so i didnt buy more. Good stuff. And really unique.This is the kind of place that makes...More

This restaurant was featured on a TV show and luckily during a trip to New York, I found it was just a few blocks away. Although $8 for a peanut butter and something sandwich may seem expensive, you definitely get your money's worth. I ordered...More

This is just such a great place to bring the whole family - kids love it, and adults are surprised at how good it is. There are also coupons ALL OVER the place to get their menu items at half price, so make sure you...More

Another surprise find Didn't realise just how much you can do with peanut butter!!! Worth a visit - staff so friendly and helpful