We get there at about 8 pm and they are out of most items. So we ordered a bit of whatever they had, and it wasn’t very good. I had the red velvet cake which was very bland and the frosting wasn’t even cream cheese...More
1 - 10 of 893 reviews
What anybody sees in this bakery is beyond me. The first time I went I bought a variety of cupcakes and a slice of hummingbird cake. The cupcakes were lousy, the hummingbird was very good. Nothing outstanding, but very good. We were in the area...More
I'm one of those who is willing to pay the price to have "been there." Years ago we "trekked" to SoHo to experience the original bakery. We were thrilled to see this one at Rockefeller on our recent stay in Midtown, and went twice! We...More
Good bakery, banana pudding is great. Everything else is above average that I've tried. Have visited a few times now. Service is good and prices are reasonable, some would say a little high, like I was when I got there. Coffee was average.
wanted to try the banana pudding but they ran out so I had to settle for the pb&j cupcake. Was unfortunately very average. Used buttercream rather than cream cheese which just made it very rich and not particularly great. Queues were also quite long at...More
Had some macaroons which were quite good but the standout was the banana pudding, lovely. Great place to catch a coffe and a cake whilst on the move.
Although quite packed when we visited, it was worth the wait. We especially liked the Apple Crumb, made to perfection! We will definitely return on our next visit to NY.
I had to try Magnolia Bakery because of friends and a particular skit called "Lazy Sunday." Magnolia Bakery is one of my favorites! I have been here 2x this year when in New York. The staff is super friendly, and everything I have gotten from...More