Great place with the best banana pudding in the world! Totally worth a visit! The coffee was not great though.
1 - 10 of 968 reviews
The best banana pudding that I have ever eaten. Hands down. Rich, creamy, sweet. Expect to wait in line for a few minutes. This bakery is sometimes credited with helping to start the "cupcake craze", but why eat cupcakes when you can eat banana pudding?
We waited for maybe 5 minutes in the cupcake line which was totally fine. The cupcakes were good, but I wouldnt have said they were mind blowingly different than anything I had before. The cake itself was dry, but the frosting was good. We also...More
usually there is a "long" line however, when you go inside of the store, the cupcake line is not that long. We tried several flavors of the cupcakes but I love the their red velvet cupcake!! It is not so sweet and very creamy with...More
All of the bakery items are quite good, but the standout is the banana pudding. I didn’t have very high expectations, but left very pleased.
I go by Magnolia Bakery every time I visit New York for the best treat during a shopping day. Beautiful and delicious cupcakes without being too sweet. Classic Vanilla is my favorite
Went to Magnolia Bakery on a midweek afternoon. It was busy on arrival and I had to queue for about ten minutes. I had the pecan and salted caramel cheesecake. It was delicious, and not that heavy by New York cheesecake standards. I would return.
My plan was to visit this bakery today for breakfast, I heard a lot about their banana pudding and red velvet pancakes, so I tried both and added a lemonade to my order. The pudding and pancakes were extremely good, just the lemonade that failed...More
We had the chocolate cheesecake (good) and java banana pudding (excellent). Highly recommend it! Staff were friendly and service was quick.
The cheese cakes came recommended as the best cheesecakes in the world. We had the vanilla and the caramel cheesecakes. They were very good, but I’m sorry to say they are not the best in the world. This honour goes to the baked caramel cheesecake...More