Ate twice last week at Pizza Barn--once with friends and once with a large group. Both times good and service were top notch. Pizza and prime rib are both tasty. We'll be back soon.
1 - 10 of 45 reviews
We had a business dinner here, evidently it was recently renovated. The local folks said it was a great update. Nice service and clean. Steaks were cooked well, however I ordered the Cajun spiced and I couldn't taste any spice on it at all. However,...More
The best part is all of the new decorations the owners did! Wes and I ate a steak dinner and loved it. The cook did a great job at seasoning and prepping our plate. This is one of my favorite places to eat for "date...More
We love the pizza, and the burgers are fresh, juicy, and yummy! The newly remodeled interior is really nice. Stop in as the sun is going down...the exterior is really cool- especially all lit up! Pam, the owner, is usually supervising and checking on guests-...More
The food was always good with a great salad bar. We ate there 4 nights in a row. This is the 2nd year to eat here and looking forward for next year.
We stayed two nights in Newcastle to travel through the western parts of the black hills as the hotels seemed to be some what cheaper. The Sage Hotel recommended us to eat at the Pizza Barn. When we arrived we were excited as the inside...More
We had the worst meal in a LONG time here. This was the first place we tried when we got to Newcastle since we foolishly believed the billboard that said it was the best food in Wyoming. It was not the best food on the...More
The food was slow but good. The bathroom is terrible. Floor and ceiling are disgusting. If we had used the bathroom before we ordered and ate half our food, we would have walked right out! No possible way the health department would pass this place...More