Really good pizza. I lived the quaint atmosphere and casual service, but we paid way too much for what we received.
1 - 10 of 50 reviews
Tony makes the best pizza for miles around. But he also gets the best price. Regardless of the price, give it a try. You'll be back each and every time you want something good. The dining room is small though, so I recommend take-out.
Loved the pizza - tossed fresh dough, all fresh ingredients and old fashioned pizza flavor with crispy edged crust. Best Pizza I have had in years! Dine in or take out!
The pizza was tasty and fresh, but not much different than a Papa Murphy's take and bake style pizza as far as freshness or seasoning, so not sure it's worth the extra money. Did carryout so can't comment on eating in.
Great Pizza. the owner is very hands on. We have been in there eating and had him come out to interact with the patrons, bring out new spreads or food items for people to try. Great to deal with for larger orders.
Recently had the Arancini Mushrooms, they were excellent! If it's a sandwich you want the Nana Maronni's Meatball Grinder is amazing. Tony's House Salad can be a meal in itself.
I work just down the street from Tony's, an we often have lunch delivered. The food is always excellent and for every 8 pies you carry out or have delivered, you get one free (Any size). This past weekend my family dined in and got...More
Outstanding pizza right in the heart of little old Sussex. They even make a great gluten-free pizza that tastes like real pizza!