We visited during a pizza tour through Milwaukee Food and City Tours. The pizza was great!! There is a large selection of drinks and menu items. Butterscotch Rootbeer was yummy.
1 - 10 of 58 reviews
I went to Classic Slice as part of a pizza bus tour. They were very well organized and ready to go. The second time I went was with my husband and daughter. The pizza is amazing. The pieces are gigantic but delicious.
I used to live near Classic Slice and would often get a slice to go. I loved the different pizza options and the extras. The service was always fast and the pizza slice size was just perfect. A little more than I needed, but not...More
A snowy night in the city. 9 patrons in the place. I knew I needed to pick up because the roads were awful. So I ordered ahead and got there in 10 minutes. Paid for my order, and then proceeded to wait 47 MINUTES for...More
We've been here a few times. They have a creative selection of topping combinations. I have never been disappointed. The slices are enormous. Thankfully they are fairly thin crust. It seems like a cheese slice or meat slice is probably a solid 1000 calories plus....More
Artisan-style pizza by the enormous slice. They had both classic flavors and inventive specialty slices as well. I had the "Meatallica" and it was loaded with meat. Unique sodas on tap with free refills was a plus. Ultimately the pizza was greasy but good -...More
The pizza here is really great. One slice will fill your plate, so it's more of a knife and fork pizza than I'm used to, but it's just so good! Nice amount of options, great service, and definitely hip enough for Bayview; this is the...More