My wife said she had fond memories of there pizza, so we along with another pizza connoisseur checked it out. All l can say is it will now be in my top 3 in Milw. I might even put it up against Balistreri Pizza. Please...More
Cataro's is a small neighborhood restaurant that has been around for a long time. They have the best pizza of the many pizza places I have tried. The thin crust tastes freshly made with the right amount of crispiness and would recommend over the pan...More
My wife drives by every day and her way to work so we decided to give it a try. It is a smaller, older restaurant but clean and somewhat cute. Their menu is somewhat limited and there is no bar. They do serve drinks and...More
There was nothing on the menu you could eat if dieting except for salad, chopped steak and perhaps minestrone soup. Everything was fried or else pasta with lots of cheese. The service was very good and friendly and the salad crisp and fresh though pretty...More
I live near this restaurant the pizza is AWESOME. No skimping on any ingredients. just make sure you bring cash they do not take credit cards.
Pizza,pizza get the thin crust pizza. Cataro's is a neighborhood pizza palace were locals gather to sit, enjoy glass of wine or beer and pizza. The vegetarian is my favorite loaded with fresh veggies and mushrooms,ask for chopped tomato. My husbnd's favorite is The Cataro's...More
I usually eat 1 slice of pizza but at Cataro's - half a 12" pizza is in my stomach before I know it. Thin crust, plenty of toppings - all fresh. Their cheese pizza is great too. Went tonight and wondered why we don't go...More