I don't know what kind of cheese this place uses, but holy cow it is so good! (We are in Wisconsin, so I suspect most places would have good cheese ;) we had 2 orders of the candle sticks and 3 different pizzas....and it was...More

My wife and I love pizza. When we travel, local pizza is one of our go-to's, and our trip to Madison was no exception. A quick scan of reviews on TripAdvisor, and we chose The Roman Candle. We had their signature pizza, the Roman Candle,...More

I've eaten at the Middleton Roman Candle Pizzeria several times and have never been disappointed. Great pizza with fresh, local ingredients and friendly service.

My 13 yr old son and I were staying at Homewood Suites after a long hot day at the US Open. Didn't feel like going out so I searched TripAdvisor for pizza delivery. Saw some good reviews on this place so pulled the trigger. The...More

I've never loved Roman Candle pizza, but some friends wanted to go so we said fine. We were very explicit with our server about our daughter's tree nut allergies and he said he would inform the kitchen, they would use clean surfaces and equipment, no...More

Great pizza. When we come to Madison we make sure to make a pitstop here. Great sauce and great service. And to go with the pizza, a tall boy PBR! Cant beat that!

have eaten at this location a few times as well as the one on Willy st and we have never had a bad pizza. Crust is delicious as are the toppings no matter what you choose. The candlesticks are fantastic as well and considering how...More

Outstanding pizza, good service, & great prices! My entire family enjoyed their dinner. The appetizers were really tasty, especially the cheesy breadsticks. The pizza was full of flavor (unlike all of the chains) and was seasoned to perfection. And it was an added bonus that...More

Great little pizzeria joint. Located on a trendy little street in Middleton. Good friendly service and a great selection of local brews. Get a salad as well. You won't be disappointed. I would definitely be a regular here.

Food is terrific, as is the service. If you cannot get a good vibe from this place, you can't get one. Not cheapest, but very very tasty.