We finally had the opportunity to have dinner at Tally-Ho. The next week, we were back again. Fantastic food, amazing service and an atmosphere that keeps inviting you back. I highly recommend Tally-Ho to anyone in the north woods.
1 - 10 of 65 reviews
A group of 8 college friends met up for a week in Hayward. I, along with my west coast friends, enjoyed the fantastic food, charming supper club vibe, and the professional yet friendly service. Tally Ho is a true Wisconsin gem!
We were looking for something nicer for dinner besides burgers and fries. Its an old style supper club with relish tray and classic ice cream drinks. Service was slow to start but then improved. Steak was great.
This place might be in the "boonies" but it is an elegant restaurant with excellent food and cocktails. We began with cocktails in the nicely decorated and comfortable bar. Then moved to the dining room and had a wonderful dinner. The manager, bartender, and waitress...More
My husband and I both loved our night at Tally Ho outside of Hayward. The service, hospitality, cocktails, cuisine, and pace were all perfect. Tablecloths and cloth napkins were also a big treat. If you're looking for a first-rate WI supper club, you will love...More
Tally Ho is a regular dinner destination and has been excellent. There has recently been a change in management and our last visit was mildly disappointing. To start the printed menu differed from the internet version and the selection that I chose on line was...More
This is a very warm, friendly venue, separate bar and dining room, the bar is great for making friends and having conversation. The dining room has a sweet fireplace, décor and white table cloths. Food is awesome especially the Italian selections. We go there for...More
Standout supper club experience. Food was outstanding. Excellent lamb chops, shrimp, and pork prime rib. Corn chowder was the best thing we had all weekend. Service was slow at times, but greatly outweighed by the charm of the staff. The tasty old fashioned didn't disappoint....More
We have been looking forward to eating a fresh walleye dinner since arriving in Hayward. What a disappointment this supper club turned out to be. My wife ordered the Special, pistachio encrusted walleye and I ordered the broiled walleye dinner. My wife said her's tasted...More
Went to the Tally Ho for our anniversary dinner. Service was great, drinks excellent and the specials of the house were fantastic. They had an appetizer of shrimp wrapped in apple wood bacon quickly deep fired that was to die for. The caprese salad was...More