This is the most popular cream parlor on Chincoteague. Ice Cream is homemade and approaches "Sinful" A must stoop
1 - 10 of 2,412 reviews
Almond Joy homemade ice cream on a real waffle cone and a dip of Oreo... the homemade nature of the ice cream is off the charts. The waffle cone was the best I'd ever had, light and crispy... matched the ice cream well. Will go...More
Would highly recommend getting ice cream here!! long line but worth it! Big portion sizes, unbeatable flavor!
My family and I have been vacationing in Chincoteague for as long as I can remember. Every year, we make sure to stop into the Island Creamery (almost every day of our trip). Expect long lines, but definitely stay because it wil be worth it....More
Worth waiting in the line for good hard ice cream. Variety of flavors from standard to unusual. We saw them making waffle cones when we walked in as well. A must have after a hot day on the beach!
I have a confession to make: I don't love ice cream. I know, I know--you're appalled. How can someone not love ice cream? Well, it's true and I don't. I really only want to eat ice cream when it's HOT outside and as a self-affirmed...More