The pies are delicious! The cakes are beautiful! The cookies melt in your mouth. Family owned and ran!
1 - 10 of 27 reviews
Over the years we have always ordered our family's birthday cakes from Mrs Goodman's. Big cakes and little cakes, rush orders and ordered ahead, all kinds of cakes and all kinds of decorations. All good and all enjoyed. I am writing this review today because...More
Pies are great. I have been getting Apple pies from here for years. Best pies in Columbus area, It is easy to get to a few block north of the center of Worthington off High street. Many times I have ordered ahead and picked up...More
Wanted appropriately decorated cake for reception after small family wedding. Granddaughter and Fiancé preferred carrot. Mrs. Goodman did 10" carrot cake w cream cheese frosting,and white on cream decoration. Beautiful cake...wonderful moist flavor...very reasonable price. Highly recommend.
I've always thought Mrs. Goodman's makes delicious scones and cookies. I just tried their cupcakes and they're just as good! I also disagree with some of the other reviewers here - the cupcakes are exceptionally moist, not at all dry. If this was a problem...More
Mrs Goodman's made my 30th bday cake and it was perfect! I asked for an 80's cake and provided them with a picture. The cake couldn't have turned out any better and I was very pleased. I can't remember the exact price I paid for...More
Mrs. Goodman's by far have the best cookies I've had :) I visit ever once in awhile to get a dozen or more cookies to share with my family. Staff also seems friendly and attentive.
If you want wonderful bake goods, come here. The rhubarb pie is one of my favorites (I like it without the strawberries), and the cakes are to die for.
Used to have the best cakes in town but lately not so great. Cakes have been dry and crumbly. Called the store but they were unwilling to resolve.
Cakes, cupcakes & cookies are all delicious. I don't bother to make my own chocolate cake from scratch when Mrs. Goodman's is better!