Had the pizza and salad buffet. Both were pretty good. Pretty average pizza. Pretty average buffet selection. I'm neither disappointed nor amazed. Cheers!
1 - 10 of 36 reviews
So we were staying in Plymouth, NC during the evacuation of Hatteras Island during Hurricane Maria, and I kept hearing the hotel staff recommend Mama's Pizza to other guests. On one of our evenings, we decided to try it, and boy, was it good! The...More
So much nicer than one of the big chains. We were welcomed as visitors in a place that seemed to be popular with local residents. The pizza was as good as you will get anywhere.
Had the manicotti and it was delicious. Some places ruin the edges of the pasta but not mama's it was cooked perfect the whole way through. Didn't try the pizza but saw a lot of it walking out the door so it's probably a safe...More
Where's Mama, because I want to tell her that this pizza just isn't good. We went in and opted for the buffet. Pizza was dried out, crust hard, toppings minimal. It reminded me of the pizza you bought in college after it had sat out...More
We had dinner here twice last week...The first time we got a sauasge and pepperoni take out pizza, which was excellent...perfectly cooked, piping hot, well seasoned and really tasty.. the other time we ate in and had a stromboli which was also quite good...It could...More
I moved to Plymouth 6 months ago and believe me if it was not for Mama's Pizza, I would leave. I always order for take-out but they do have eat in with a very nice dining area. I am not a pizza person because most...More