Needed a quick meal on the go, stopped by for a slice. Pizza was heated quickly and cooked to perfection. $2.00 a piece, not a bad deal.
11 - 20 of 48 reviews
Ordered a massive dinner for an entire baseball team. They got the order right and it was ready when they said it would be. The food was pretty good. Of course, it isn't NYC pizza, but it isn't bad at all.
I have a sister who is allergic to cheese, so I asked for an antipasto salad without cheese. They agreed but then had to remake salad because cheese was used. I got the impression that they thought I was lying to them. I will not...More
Best pizza in the area! Worth the trip if you are staying nearby while your child is participating @ Cooperstown Dreams Park, or if you are in the area for Glimmerglass Opra. Nice place to eat in or take out. Relaxed atmosphere. Friendly staff, hometown...More
I order pizza from here and they made it the way I wanted it. The owners here are great people and all the staff is great as well. Pizza here is the BEST around. I DO NOT eat at the chains anymore. Nice thing is...More
Following a hot day at the beach in Cooperstown, I was hungry, but I knew I didn't want a big meal or anything expensive. I had stopped at NY Pizzeria for the first time in July and enjoyed a meatball tunnel. This time, I ordered...More
DH and I stopped here for a quick bite after a long day in nearby Cooperstown. We ordered garlic knots and Sicilian pizza - both were very good. The place is clean, service is friendly, and prices are reasonable. You place your order at the...More
Small pizzerias can be on the scary side, usually either amazing or downright awful. This one took the cake, I got a large with several toppings and it was baked just the right amount. Didn't take long to make either!