Wouldn't hesitate to come back. Staff was friendly and the place has a cozy vibe. The portions are a generous size. A highlight of our stay in Montauk.
1 - 10 of 180 reviews
Way more than just a local Pub although long a favorite of Locals. Roast Duck is great and they always have a fish of the day special. Great Burgers. Wonderful Staff and Ella and Chet are great Hosts.
The Service was very good O'mushy's Pub is very well priced. I liked the French Dip Sliced Roast Beef Au Jus. The fries were also good. I also enjoyed the multi-colored tortilla chips.
While staying at Kenny's Tipperary Inn next door, we ate twice at O'Murphy's and loved it! Cute, homey decor with delightful and efficient service ... with the owner on the premises, so careful attention was paid to customers. Our son, a beef lover, had a...More
stopped at O'Murphys twice while we were vacationing on Montauk, and neither time did it disappoint. Good size menu, with plenty of seafood items, but also meat entrees like Hungaran Goulash, which was absolutely excellent and Shepherds Pie, and lamb stew. Never did find a...More
This restaurant is on the grounds of Kenny's Tipperary Inn, walking distance to our room at the hotel. Friendly, courteous waitstaff. They advised us of the specials, and timed the food so that we were able to eat our meal without being rushed. The restaurant...More
We liked this place so much the first night for dinner, we ate there every night we stayed in montauk . Great staff and very good food that comes to the table HOT! Check out the soups , steak , pork chops and nice calamari....More
The Hamptons have become very expensive and I am constantly looking for places to eat that are quality without ridiculous price. O'Murphy's is just that. My go to is a plate of buffalo wings that are as good as any I've had. You can order...More