Went here on a a Saturday morning. The place was very busy. Ordered a bagel sandwich to go. Thought this would take 10 minutes or so, 15 at most. I was very wrong. After ordering, it took over a half hour for the order to...More
1 - 10 of 14 reviews
Located in Bayberry Plaza off of County Route 91 (aka Route 57) Bagelicious is a cozy diner offering good food for a decent price. They bake their own bagels and have a wide offering of cream cheeses. They also offer standard breakfast and lunch fare....More
Amazing bagels! Management needs to take a strong look at what causes a 20 minute wait for such a routine item as eggs and bagels. The bacon was of a poor quality and under undercooked for what is the usual preference of people regarding bacon....More
Great Bagels, Good coffee, Many creme cheese flavors that are home made on the premises. Plus they serve sandwiches and other breakfast choices
Ate lunch here recently and was pleasantly surprised with the taste and value of our meal. Definitely will be back.
This crowded, but homey breakfast/luncheon location offers all types of bagels made in-house, along with a breakfast and luncheon menu. Located next to Kinney's in Bayberry Plaza, they also have a new location farther north on Route 57. Their bagels are particularly good - with...More
Your French Toast bagel - WOW!!!! Best bagels in town, period. B-fast sandwiches are also amazing. The only reason this isn't a 5/5 rating is because I think the coffee selection and display/presentation could be improved.