From the day it opened more than 2 decades ago, to a fabulous birthday dinner last Saturday night, Nick & Toni's always delivers great food and great service in a relaxed atmosphere.
Does this restaurant serve alcohol?
Is this restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Does this restaurant have tables with seating?
Does this restaurant have a full bar?
Does this restaurant have waiters and waitresses?
Can a gluten free person get a good meal at this restaurant?
Can a vegetarian person get a good meal at this restaurant?
Is this restaurant good for brunch?
Does this restaurant offer outdoor seating?
Is this restaurant good for dinner?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
If you're looking for a great dining experience , great quality foods , great portions as well as a professional/ friendly staff then here is a great choice . Joe and his staff at will satisfy your every need . Be sure to make a reservation as they tend to pack them in here and don't be surprised if you're... More
Like a lot of celebrities nowadays, this restaurant has become famous for being famous. Scratch the surface of its local allure, however, and what we've found is average food at above-average prices. I go to Nick&Tony's simply for the warm greeting from the front staff and the elegant martinis mixed by Kevin, the barman. But the cuisine is consistently uninspired.... More
Five of us met here for brunch last Sunday and are not convinced the menu is irresistible. My off-the-menu local mushroom frittata with salad was a bit dry. The eggs Benedict was good, but the pizza with broccoli and cheese had a thin crust and was just ok. We asked for poached eggs over the hash dish, but they came... More
I never really understand the crowds Nick& Toni's attracts, especially in the summer. The location is just off a commercial street and is surrounded by a large parking lot. The decor is casual with lots of modern art. An amuse-bouche of crab salad on cucumber was mushy and unflavorful.A citrus salad has arugula leaves that had turned black and slimy... More
We have been going to this restaurant for years. It is always good. We have never had a bad meal. If your not into a big dinner the pastas are always a great choice. The ingredients they use are always the best and when available they seem to use local produce. The only problem with this restaurant is that it's... More
Nick and Toni's is a wonderful restaurant. We celebrated our anniversary there. The menu is extensive and delicious. Appetizers, main course, drinks desserts all perfect. Service is great. This a place you must go if you visit the Hamptons. Their Zucchini chips and Tartufo are yummy!!
After reading my previous review the management team of Nick and Toni's reached out to me and apologized for the problems that I had written about. They promised to make my future visits more welcoming and gave me the names and number of people who would make sure that I was able to make reservations and obtain the wonderful service... More
Nick & Toni's has a long and storied history and will be around long after my review is published (but not the NYC location) - I recently had dinner there and expected so much but perhaps that was the problem. For the record, all the employees, host, owner and management made me and my dining companion feel very welcome -... More
Great atmosphere and food is always fresh . Vegetables grown locally. Everyone very nice. Excellent service. The chief is fantastic. Owners friendly and will greet you. Been going there over twenty years.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing