I’m from New York City and your pizza definitely keeps up with them! Got 4 different slices all were amazing!
1 - 10 of 371 reviews
The sauce on that pizza is horrendous. You guys should smile from ear to ear instead of having a sour puss on everyday,reason being,that someone is actually buying your slop !! PS: CLEAN YOUR PLACE UP, its oct 27,your not busy,its a ghost town now....then...More
Had a late lunch here after visiting the Baseball HoF down the street. They were busy, which is a good sign. They have a great selection of slices, as well as other menu items. We just had slices which were headed to a crisp perfection....More
Stopped in for lunch one day. Had the stuffed shells and they were delicious. The chicken parm was average. The place is just an average looking pizza parlor. It is a good place to grab a quick lunch.
After visiting Cooperstown for 3 days, we visited Sal's twice. Loved the broccoli and cheese pizza and yesterday's Manhattan Clam Chowder soup hit the spot.
Staff was nice. Pizza was so-so. They have a kind of a captive audience, especially in October when many of the businesses are closed or closing for the year, so choices are limited. Service was good, but the product left a lot to be desired
We ordered slices and they were good. The Sal's Special slice was very good. Bathroom was disgusting, overall the place wasn't clean. Great location. Prices as expected.
I go to Sal's every time I'm in Cooperstown, which is usually at least once a year. They give you a choice of 6 or 7 different kinds of pizza by the slice. My favorite is sausage and mushroom. Very nice pizza parlor feel to...More