Easily the best Italian restaurant in a 30 mile radius. Roaring fire in the pizza brick oven, friendly bar, lovely outdoor patio and absolutely delicious food.
1 - 10 of 187 reviews
We have enjoyed meeting friends at Cosimo’s for lunch for several years now. Winter, or any other season, it’s a great way to enjoy a comfortable meal with friends in a relaxed and pleasant atmosphere. It has become our favorite “meet up” spot, so that...More
Jacklyn my server was good but was overwhelmed that night. I ordered the Boscaiola pasta and an Ithaca apricot wheat ale. The meal was decent but the pasta was not cooked enough and had a lot of chew. The sauce was also sparse.
We went with a crown for a family gathering - used the wine room with a set menu. Most of us found the food to be very bland - Chicken Francaise - supposed to be lemony - no taste at all.. pasta sauce lackluster at...More
I stayed at a local hotel in the area for two nights on business and made it a point to have dinner at Cosimo's both nights. Being a business traveler, I almost always sit at the bar and did so both of these nights (Monday...More
Warm and inviting atmosphere, huge menu, delicious food and excellent service. I've eaten here twice, once with a very large group and once with three people and the food and service were great each time. Mainly Italian dishes, including fabulous brick oven pizzas, but a...More
We made a quick trip to the outlet mall nearby but read about Cosimo's on TripAdvisor and thought it would be better than any of the fast food at the mall. We both had pizza- mine had eggplant and my husband's had spinach and ricotta....More
We've eaten here probably a hundred times. Always fresh food, respectful of dietary restrictions, fairly priced, touching all bases from meat to seafood to pasta and vegetarian entrees. Most friendly staff, great service. Handicap accessible. Parking on a busy weekend evening can be problematic but...More
Since this review, I have been to another location in middletown ny. Hands down the central valley ny location has better pizza makers. In addition, the central valley location has a better exhaust system during my visit. The Middletown exhaust system is terrible too smokey...More