We were in Bemus for a wedding. Had dinner at Italian and, other that too big proportions, was excellent. One of the best restaurants around.
1 - 10 of 209 reviews
We were looking forward to having a wonderful anniversary meal and were so disappointed. The cheese plate was excellent, the salads average, but the peppered steaks were totally covered in pesto and cold. The waitress was not fully trained on the menu (sweet but not...More
The Bemus Bay Pops is housed here and they provide entertainment in the summer season. For the local person to go here for dinner it would have to be an occasion to spend your time on the lake front for a special reason or you...More
I won't eat dinner here again. The food isn't worth the exorbitant price they charge. The only positive about this restaurant is that it's on the lake. I ordered a mojito, and the drink I received had hardly any mint in it; the mint it...More
The food was really great and you get massive portions, although it is slightly expensive. We really enjoyed our meal and the service was excellent. You have a choice of eating inside or out, with great views over Lake Erie - I would go back...More
I had gone to a big benefit, spent lots of money on raffles, baskets, etc.. I won a Pasta dinner at The Italian Fisherman. It closed for the season; before I received my certificate. So I waited until this summer; when I was Hungry for...More
My husband and I took a ride recently and ended up in Bemus Point. We stopped and had a wonderful dinner at the Italian Fisherman. We thought it was a bit prices ($9 for a salad and $9 for soup); the meal itself was worth...More