Best Pizza in Phillipsburg. Very good sauce. This local establishment has been around for years. They only serve pizza and take cash only.
1 - 10 of 41 reviews
I ordered a large pizza with double pepperoni and picked it up after getting a haircut next door. When the pizza was being cut, I saw only a few slices of pepperoni on it, so I asked if it was double pepperoni. The fellow who...More
I have lived close by for 20+ years. they always use to have a good pie, somewhere in the early 2000's the quality went down so i stopped going. went back again tonight for the firs time in like 15 years. the two pizza men...More
This is your Typical Pizzeria , The Pizza is a Local Tradition. One of the Oldest in the Phillipsburg Area . They make an Excellent Traditional pie the Sicilian pizza has a great crust. Still family run.
Delicious pizza! When the kid's come home from out of state, they have to visit Nicolosi's for pizza. They even get one to go home - to Florida! Just beware, cash only.
This is a P'Burg landmark. The best pizza in town. Also claims to be the oldest pizzaria in NJ. Fantastic and greasy when it is fresh. Menu limited to basically pizza but this is the place to stop.
I was born in Philly and have lived in the Philly/NJ/NY area all of my life. This is the best pizza that I have ever had. It provides the perfect ratio of sauce, cheese and crust. I currently live about 45 minutes from this location...More