We were in Jersey and visited this restaurant. Did not have Coke or Pepsi products. Asked if meatballs were homemade; they were not. No substitutions. Pizza had a very thin crust --- runny cheese
1 - 10 of 168 reviews
I go there when I want a great pizza. The food overall is excellent, but no one beats their pizza. Order it well done; it gives more crunch and stability to the dough.
Overall, Star Tavern is a great experience and if anything, a unique one. I scored it 3/5 but it could have been a 4/5. Problem is, it wasn't "average" (a 3) but it certainly wasn't "very good" (a 4). As an experience, it was great....More
Went with friends on a Thursday evening and enjoyed their mussels, Sicilian pie and another regular pie. All with great service at one of their side booths. Got there early before 6:00 pm so we were immediately seated. A line started to form about an...More
Loud, noisy, busy, cluttered, parking stinks, neighborhood is sketchy, omg those long lines, watch your back, paper plates! seriously? and I wouldn't want it any other way! say hello to Brenda, why don't ya!
I grew up coming here when I was a kid, the place has still the same quality food and always brings back great memories every time we come here. Love the pizza here and always look forward to the next time I can get back...More
We went for the pizza of course. It is very good. Ask for it well done. Only one of our 5 was crispy. We got a plain, pepperoni, eggplant, red spinach and olive medley. The favorites were the olive-very briney and the eggplant. The eggplant...More
As confirmed by everyone else who reviewed Star, the pizza here is phenomenal!!!! My daughters just got back from spring break trip to Ireland and both were like, "take us to Star"!!!! Done. Wings were good as well but it's the pizza that is far...More
The pizza is outstanding! Best pizza in the area. Good selection of beers too! This is perfect for lunch or dinner but it gets packed so get there early.